LLC Liability Protection (Myths, Realities and Charging Orders)
Table Of Contents

Can you be sued personally if you operate an LLC? Yes. And you can easily lose on both a business and a personal level. There are several myths out there regarding the use of an LLC as a shelter from lawsuits and litigation. Some of the hype has been created by attorneys who used to charge upwards of $1,000 to form an LLC. Need to pay for condos in Maui, presumably. We accountants tease attorneys that LLC really means Lawyer’s Likely Choice.
Sidebar: LLCs are quite powerful. As discussed in other sections, the deal structures within the entity are endless, and the flexibility is strong within multi-entity arrangements. Let’s not forget that solid estate planning can be achieved with an LLC as well.
Back to picking on attorneys. Remember, attorneys are not necessarily smart because they went to law school. People are smart, and smart attorneys are people who were already smart and then chose law as a profession. To be fair, the same is true for accountants and doctors. In other words, if you are not smart, school doesn’t fix you.
While consultation with an experienced attorney is strongly recommended for your unique situation, as business owners ourselves we feel the excitement of the LLC has overshadowed the reality of our litigious society. If your acts, errors or omissions injure someone, even under the auspice of your LLC, there is a good chance you will be personally named in the lawsuit and held liable.
For this discussion, here’s who enjoys limited liability-
| Entity | Owners Shielded From Entity Debts? |
| LLC (including one taxed as an S Corp) | Yes |
| Corporation (C Corp or S Corp) | Yes |
| Limited liability partnership (LLP) | Yes, for the partners |
| Limited partnership (LP) | Limited partners yes, general partner no |
| Limited liability limited partnership (LLLP) | Yes, including the general partner |
| General partnership | No |
| Sole proprietorship | No |
Sure, this is a huge generality, and exceptions always exist depending on agreements and state law.
Inside and Outside Liability
Attorneys split liability protection into two directions-
- Inside liability. Someone has a claim against your LLC, such as an injured customer, an unpaid vendor or a lender. Can they reach you personally? Generally no, unless it was your own conduct, you signed a personal guarantee, or a court pierces the veil.
- Outside liability. Someone has a claim against you personally, such as a car accident on a Saturday. Can they reach your LLC? That’s where charging orders come in.
An LLC helps on both fronts, just not as much as the internet promised.
Your Own Acts Follow You
There are three areas where you can be held personally responsible: criminal, contractual and torts. Torts are probably most people’s concern, and torts can either be-
- Negligence, where you have a general duty to act in a reasonable way and you didn’t (like driving your car safely).
- Intentional torts, where there was a purposeful act to harm. Kinda rare, right?
There are other tort buzzwords like gross negligence, careless disregard and defamation. Remember, negligence is the opposite of diligence.
The general rule across the country is that individuals are personally liable for their own tortious conduct, even when they were acting on behalf of a business. The LLC doesn’t change that. If you owned shares of Ford Motor Company, you weren’t personally responsible for the damage caused by the Ford Pinto. But a corporate officer who ignored the potential for harm could be held responsible, even criminally. In other words, fix that loose railing before your tenant hurts himself, LLC or no LLC. Smell gas next to the hot water heater? Get that fixed!
You are a reasonable person. Does it seem reasonable for someone to hide behind an LLC or a corporation when they do bad things? Of course not, and public policy doesn’t allow it. If you personally ignore a dangerous condition you’re responsible for fixing, or you’re reckless while driving the business car, you should be sued, and you should lose. The LLC isn’t going to make that negligence disappear. Our judicial system would come to a halt if it were easy to hide behind an LLC.
And if you own multiple investments and LLCs, thinking you can protect the others when one goes sideways, think again. If you face a credible lawsuit arising out of your own acts or omissions, the injured party’s attorney is going to pursue everything you have, including your personal residence, cars, college funds, your interests in your other LLCs, your Snuggie collection and so on. Yes, even the leopard one.
What an LLC (or Corporation) Does Protect You From
Here’s the good news after all that gloom. An LLC protects you from other people’s acts. If your employee rear-ends someone on a delivery run, the LLC is on the hook, but you aren’t personally liable simply because you own the LLC, unless you were careless in hiring or supervising that employee. The same goes for a co-owner’s mistakes. And the LLC’s debts and contracts generally stay the LLC’s problem, as long as you didn’t personally guarantee them. That’s real protection. It just isn’t protection from yourself.
Piercing the Veil (Rare, but Real)
Piercing the corporate veil is when a court ignores the entity and holds the owners personally responsible for the entity’s debts. It’s rare, and it usually takes more than bad luck, such as-
- Commingling personal and business funds.
- Ignoring the entity’s separateness.
- Using the entity to commit fraud.
Courts apply the same thinking to LLCs, and small, closely held entities are where it happens, since that’s where the owner and the business blur together. Does that sound like your LLC? Yes. Could it happen to you? Yes. Is there a small chance of this happening? Who knows? We say risk it, put it all on red and let it ride. Just kidding. No one bets on red.
What about Enron? Different animal. Those executives went to prison for their own fraud, not because a court pierced anything. That’s the your-own-acts rule again, with handcuffs, like real ones.
Capitalization matters, but mostly in one situation. Courts rarely pierce the veil just because an LLC is thin. Where owners get burned is emptying the LLC once trouble shows up. In a Colorado Springs case, an LLC sold its only significant asset, an airplane, and distributed the money to its sole member while a dispute over an airplane hangar construction contract was still being litigated. The court pierced the veil and held the owner personally liable for what the LLC owed (Martin v. Freeman, 272 P.3d 1182 (Colo. App. 2012)). Leave the LLC holding the bag on purpose, and the bag becomes yours.
Commingling and Housekeeping
Some attorneys will argue that if you mix personal and business funds together, even accidentally, you might erode the separation between you and the business. For example, a business owner pays for car insurance through the business, but the car is owned personally and the owner is reimbursed for mileage. On the books, the car insurance isn’t a deductible business expense and gets coded as an owner draw or shareholder distribution. Do that enough, and a court might decide the veil between you and the business is getting thin, perhaps too thin.
Same with minutes and other business governance. Some argue that if you don’t keep up with the housekeeping of your business, you chip away at the protection. Many state LLC laws say skipping formalities isn’t, by itself, a reason to pierce the veil, but there is a natural human response to pile on once a defect is discovered. “In closing, your honor, on top of Exhibits A through AJ, this LLC failed to record basic business governance.” While we doubt how much weight that would carry, it certainly helps paint a picture of carelessness. As mentioned elsewhere, LLCs generally don’t document meetings or minutes unless the state requires it.
Insurance Is the Real Shield
So, what do you do? In addition to your general business liability insurance, secure a decent umbrella policy at both the personal and commercial level. This is our strong recommendation for liability arising from your acts, errors and omissions. Premiums depend on the limits and your risk profile, so get quotes. Note that your liability limits on the underlying assets, such as buildings, rental properties and cars, might have to increase to reach the floor (starting point) of the umbrella policy. This prevents gaps in coverage.
An umbrella policy isn’t a substitute for professional liability, errors and omissions, employment practices or other specialized coverage. Errors and omissions insurance varies depending on your profession (realtor versus financial advisor versus insurance sales). Make sure the policies actually cover the risks your business creates.
Many credible lawsuits settle within the limits of available coverage to avoid lengthy and expensive trial litigation. Again, please consult your attorney and insurance agent for your unique situation.
Insurance is the business of selling fear, so there you go.
Borrowing, Guarantees and Contracts
LLCs and corporations protect the owners from being personally responsible for the business’s debts and obligations, unless the owners personally guarantee them. In today’s lending climate, it is very difficult to get a business loan in the name of the LLC without signing a personal guarantee. In other words, you will more than likely sign twice: first, as the person directing the business to borrow, and second, as an individual promising to pay should the business fail to do so.
Sidebar: Business owners tell us often that they want the LLC to create credit history and therefore worthiness. Sure, if you are a massive company with tangible assets. However, most closely held small businesses will never have credit worthiness to the extent that the lender will not require personal guarantees. Stop chasing this dream.
Lenders also talk about recourse and nonrecourse. A recourse loan lets the lender come after the borrower beyond the collateral. A nonrecourse loan limits the lender to the collateral itself, typically the property. Nonrecourse loans are tough to get, can be expensive and require significant equity (around 60% loan-to-value or less is a common rule of thumb in our experience). And read the fine print. Most nonrecourse commercial loans have “bad boy” carve-outs that make you personally liable if you commit fraud, transfer the property without the lender’s consent or commit similar sins. There’s a “bad girl” version too.
Quick Recap: Small business lenders often protect themselves twice. First, they take a lien on property, giving them collateral if the loan goes bad. Second, they ask you to personally guarantee repayment. If the business defaults, the lender can pursue the collateral and, depending on the loan documents, pursue you for whatever is still owed. Two prods into your world.
Here’s how the protection works when it works. Let’s say you own three businesses. One LLC operates a pizza joint, another LLC owns a rental with a ton of equity, and a third LLC trades stocks, bonds and options. The rental was purchased with a nonrecourse loan. The rental house develops extensive mold, isn’t insured for mold, and eventually is foreclosed, leaving some creditors holding the bag. Picture the poor guy in Monopoly. Those creditors cannot seize your pizza joint or your portfolio, since they are held in other LLCs. This is an overly simplified example, and there are rare and narrow instances where you could still be in trouble, but generally this affords some protection.
A common arrangement is the self-rental. You operate your business in one LLC and buy the office building in another, ideally with a nonrecourse loan, while the business has its own line of credit. Depending on how the debt is structured, each asset has a Chinese Wall between them. Don’t laugh; that wall served well for nearly 3,000 years. See our Real Estate Holding Company and Operating Company section for more information.
Again, banks are smart. You are not the first Tom, Dick or Harry to come around. We should probably update the names to reflect the current smattering. How about you’re not the first Parker, Logan or Dakota to come around with your androgynous name and lofty schemes. Most lenders require personal guarantees on every loan.
Contracts work the same way. If you sign a contract for internet service, a copier lease or some other commitment in the LLC’s name, and you don’t personally guarantee it, the LLC might be liable for the remaining obligation, but you personally might not be. Keep in mind that a creditor with a judgment against the LLC can go after everything the LLC owns, including its bank accounts and receivables. Your business could be emptied even if your personal assets are safe.
One more crack in the shield, and it’s a big one for S Corp owners. If your business withholds payroll taxes from employees, including you, and doesn’t send them to the IRS, the responsible person can be held personally liable for the unpaid withholding through the trust fund recovery penalty. The LLC doesn’t stop it. Neither does the S Corp election. Payroll taxes get paid first, period.
How about we just keep our promises and pay our bills, huh?
Inside Liability at a Glance
Here’s the inside liability scorecard-
| Your LLC Generally Protects You From | Your LLC Doesn’t Protect You From |
| Your employees’ mistakes, unless you were careless in hiring or supervising them | Your own negligence or bad acts |
| Your co-owners’ mistakes | Debts and leases you personally guaranteed |
| The LLC’s debts and contracts you didn’t guarantee | Bad boy carve-outs on a nonrecourse loan |
| A judgment against the LLC reaching your personal assets | Unpaid payroll withholding (the trust fund recovery penalty) |
| Veil piercing when you empty or commingle the LLC |
Charging Orders (Protecting Your Partners From Your Creditors)
Now flip it around. You have personal financial trouble, and one of your creditors comes after your LLC interest. In most states, instead of seizing the LLC or its assets, the creditor gets a charging order, which is a lien on your share of any distributions. The creditor gets no vote and can’t force the LLC to make a distribution. The theory is simple: if your business partner has financial trouble, why should it be your problem? Your only problem should be where to send their distribution check.
Read that again, because it’s the whole point. Charging orders protect your partners from your creditors more than they protect you. They do real work when the co-owners are unrelated, or span generations, and one member gets sued personally. They’re thin almost everywhere else-
- Single-member LLCs. There’s no partner to protect, so many states let creditors take the whole interest. A Colorado bankruptcy court let the trustee step in and take control of a debtor’s single-member LLC outright (In re Albright, 291 B.R. 538 (Bankr. D. Colo. 2003)).
- Foreclosure states. Some states, Colorado among them (WCG’s home state), permit creditors to foreclose on an LLC interest. The buyer generally receives the economic rights, not an automatic right to manage the business. In 2024, the Tenth Circuit went further, concluding that Colorado charging orders aren’t necessarily a creditor’s exclusive remedy, which opens the door to other collection tools, such as ordering the interest sold (Bartch v. Barch, 111 F.4th 1043 (10th Cir. 2024)). You might keep your vote while losing every dime the interest would ever pay. Yuck.
- Married members. If you both signed for the debt, the creditor charges both interests and there’s nothing left to protect. In community property states, community assets are generally reachable for either spouse’s debts. And when the debtor and the only other member share a bed, a judge isn’t going to see an innocent co-owner who needs shielding.
That’s why adding your spouse to make your LLC multi-member is thin protection, and it can add a partnership tax return to the mix. See our Your Spouse as a Business Partner section for more information.
As a side note, here is Delaware’s verbiage about charging orders under Title 6, Section 18-703–
(d) The entry of a charging order is the exclusive remedy by which a judgment creditor of a member or a member’s assignee may satisfy a judgment out of the judgment debtor’s limited liability company interest and attachment, garnishment, foreclosure or other legal or equitable remedies are not available to the judgment creditor, whether the limited liability company has 1 member or more than 1 member.
Makes you want to run out and form your LLC in Delaware, doesn’t it? But if you form in Delaware and live and operate in Colorado, which state’s charging order rules a Colorado court will apply isn’t always settled. And if you’re marching into court with a boatload of financial woes and hanging your hat on a charging order, you might have bigger problems. Creditors are wise to this, which is why they make you personally guarantee the obligation in the first place.
Sidebar: Charging orders protect LLC interests, not corporate stock. A creditor of a shareholder in a state-law corporation can generally go after the shares directly. An LLC taxed as an S Corp keeps the LLC’s charging order protection, which is one more reason we prefer an LLC with an S Corp election over incorporating. One catch: if a creditor forecloses on the interest, the new holder could be an ineligible S Corp shareholder, such as a lender’s corporation, and the election could terminate.
Trusts (Probate Yes, Protection No)
Does a living trust protect you from lawsuits? Everyone seems to have a revocable living trust these days, and plenty of people think it does. It doesn’t. You can change it, revoke it and pull assets out whenever you like, so the law treats those assets as still yours, and so do your creditors. A living trust is great at avoiding probate and keeping your affairs private when you die. That’s its job.
Irrevocable trusts are a different story-
- Trusts for someone else. A trust you set up for your kids with a spendthrift clause can protect the assets from their creditors, and from their future ex-spouses. The price is that you’ve given the assets away.
- Trusts for yourself. A trust where you’re also a beneficiary is generally reachable by your creditors, except in the states that allow domestic asset protection trusts, which come with waiting periods and plenty of fine print.
Timing applies here too. Moving assets into any trust after a claim shows up can be undone by a court.
Where to Form Your LLC (Home State Usually Wins)
This is about formation state from a liability perspective; we cover nexus from an income tax perspective in Chapter 5. Many business entities are formed in what people perceive as business-friendly states, such as Delaware or Nevada. But when it comes to liability, especially tort liability, you will generally be sued where you have an economic or physical presence.
Yes, an attorney will show up and attempt to fight jurisdiction. But they might lose. Now you’re hiring an out-of-state attorney to fight your out-of-state lawsuit. Sounds like a grand plan.
So, if you form your LLC in Delaware, maintain a presence in Kansas and cause damages in Kansas, you will probably be sued in Kansas. Kansas courts do apply Delaware law to an LLC’s internal affairs, including whether members are liable for the LLC’s debts. But no state’s LLC law protects you from your own conduct, and you’ll pay to register and maintain the LLC in both states. Contracts can dictate which state’s law governs, but if you march into court pinning your hopes on another state’s law to save you, you’re probably better off mediating, settling and moving on down the line.
Also, most parties want the case in their own backyard. You trip and fall in a Wal-Mart and sue Wal-Mart, you are not flying to Bentonville, Arkansas to file the lawsuit. Although Table Rock Lake to the north of Bentonville is amazing, you want to sue in your local town, using local courts and jurors. After your big fat judgment, fly to Table Rock Lake in your private jet. Good stuff!
If you have a presence in all 50 states, using Wal-Mart as an example again, you must pick a state to call home regardless (your domicile) and then register as a foreign entity everywhere else. Picking a business-friendly state makes sense when operations span several states, contracts are frequent, and your attorneys know that state’s law inside and out.
For 99% of small business owners out there, keep it simple and organize in your home state. You really have only two major concerns-
- Where contract disputes will be argued, which can be dictated within the contract.
- Tort liability, which is mitigated with insurance and being a diligent human being.
Yet another example. A lot of real estate investors will organize in Nevada because of the seemingly friendly business laws and then buy rental properties in Colorado. That requires a foreign entity registration in Colorado, and it is a near guarantee that if you are grossly negligent in maintaining your rental, you will be sued in Colorado. So why the heck are we forming in Nevada? Or Wyoming? Or Delaware? Do you know anyone in all your walks of life who fought a lawsuit based on some other state’s law? Perhaps, but sleeping at night solely on this layer of protection might not be that comforting.
There are situations, such as several remote principals collaborating on a business, where the home state becomes murky. WCG CPAs & Advisors has a client where three brothers own a hotel in a Caribbean country. We formed a Florida LLC, since two brothers lived in the foreign country and the third in New York. Another client has three principals living in Oregon, Texas and New Jersey. We formed the entity in Wyoming and registered it as a foreign entity in each state.
Equity Stripping and Other Asset Protection Tools
Another asset protection strategy that is older than dirt is equity stripping, and it doesn’t need an LLC at all. You borrow against your assets so there’s little equity left for a creditor to chase, then keep the cash somewhere harder to reach. The legitimate version uses real lenders, such as a cash-out refinance or a line of credit, with the proceeds moved into assets the law protects.
The bogus version is the friendly lien, where your own Nevada corporation records a lien against your own property. Courts toss those as fraudulent transfers, now often called voidable transfers. Equity stripping can be a good asset protection strategy, but it requires careful planning with a skilled attorney, and you’re paying interest on money you borrowed just to look poor. And no, it is not older than dirt, but it has been around for quite some time.
A few other tools deserve a mention-
- Insurance first. Covered above, and still the best dollar you’ll spend.
- Separate LLCs for separate risks. One LLC per rental property keeps a lawsuit on one from reaching the others. Our rental book, I Just Got a Rental, What Do I Do?, digs into this.
- Exempt assets. ERISA-covered retirement plans generally have strong creditor protection. Solo 401k plans, which cover only you and your spouse, aren’t ERISA plans, so their protection outside bankruptcy depends on state law, although federal bankruptcy protections still apply. IRAs and homesteads have their own exemptions, with limits and rules that vary by state.
- Domestic asset protection trusts. A growing number of states, including South Dakota, Wyoming and Nevada, allow them. Definitely attorney stuff, with waiting periods and fine print.
- Timing. Asset protection is fire insurance. Buy it before the fire. Once a claim exists or is on the horizon, moving assets around can be undone by a court and can make things worse.
You can also act in a diligent way, and not do things that reasonable people might call stupid. Remember Forrest Gump, stupid is as stupid does.
Keep It Simple (The 10-Slide Deck Problem)
There’s a cottage industry selling layered entity structures. Your rental is owned by an LLC, which is owned by a Wyoming holding company, which is owned by a land trust, with 2% held by a management corporation in Nevada for good measure. It looks impressive on a whiteboard.
Sidebar: A land trust is typically a revocable trust that holds title to real estate so the owner’s name stays off the public records, while the owner, as beneficiary, keeps full control and all the benefits. That’s privacy, not protection, since a revocable trust you control is still yours as far as your creditors and the IRS are concerned.
Here’s what it actually does-
- More paperwork. More tax returns, registered agents and state fees, every single year. California charges its $800 annual LLC tax to each one.
- More chances to slip. Every extra entity is another bank account to keep separate and another set of records to maintain, which is exactly what veil piercing feeds on.
- More confusion. Lenders and insurance companies scratch their heads, and so do the folks preparing your tax returns. Want to refinance? Good luck.
- Nothing for your own negligence. If you’re the one who ignored the loose railing, the stack of entities doesn’t help. Insurance does.
Privacy isn’t protection either. Hiding who owns what makes you harder to find, not harder to collect from, and in front of a judge, a structure built mainly to make you hard to find looks like exactly that. If you need a 10-slide deck to explain your entity structure, you’ve lost the room and the case.
For most real estate investors, the answer is boring: an LLC per rental (or a few low-risk ones grouped together), good property insurance and an umbrella policy. Boring wins.


This KB article is an excerpt from our 420+ page book (some picture pages, but no scatch and sniff) which is available in paperback from 

