Skip to main content
Knowledge Base
Print

Operating Agreements (What Attorneys Often Miss)

Operating Agreements (What Attorneys Often Miss)

What should an operating agreement include? If you are a single-member LLC, or your business partner is your spouse, maybe not much, although divorce attorneys might disagree. But if you are in business with another person, even a brother or sister-in-law, then a beefy Operating Agreement is a must have, at least eventually. Long before the money flows or there is real value.

Operating Agreements are like Bylaws for an LLC. They protect the rights of the members and define the parameters in which the members can operate. In general, attorneys do an adequate job drafting this critical document, but there are some holes that WCG CPAs & Advisors feels compelled to mention.

Death, Divorce, Incapacitation

Death and divorce are easy, and attorneys have these in their templates all the time. Incapacitation, however, is often left out or only briefly mentioned. What happens if your business partner is neither dead nor divorced but can no longer make decisions or do the job? Without a contractually obligated and legally enforceable plan, you might be stuck with a partner who can’t participate and can’t be bought out.

Do you need one doctor? Two doctors? What is the triggering threshold? Traumatic brain injuries are more common than you think, and it isn’t just mental incapacity either. Your business might suffer if a member can’t physically perform their role. And once a buyout is triggered, how is it paid for? Life and disability buyout insurance can fund what the Operating Agreement promises.

Accounting and Corporate Waste

Most attorneys draft language allowing any member to request a formal accounting of the expenditures and financial records, and most state LLC statutes give members that right anyway. What they often neglect is thresholds where all members must sign off. For example, let’s say you are a minority member at 25%, and the other three members are also 25% each. Interestingly, the other three are also a voting block since they are all family members. What’s to prevent them from buying a business car for someone other than you?

Consider requiring unanimous or supermajority approval for things like-

  • Owner compensation changes.
  • Vehicles and other expenses that benefit a particular owner.
  • Transactions with an owner or an owner’s relatives.
  • Borrowing above a set amount.
  • Admitting new members.

Cash businesses deserve extra attention. If you’re a minority investor in a bar, restaurant or car wash, don’t you want a little assurance that the majority owner is not skimming the till? Did you know the IRS can estimate a bar’s sales without trusting the deposits? They look at purchases, which is easy since most bars must buy from a distributor, apply a markup for the area, and boom, they have sales regardless of what the bank statements say. Same with divorces, where lifestyle and spending are used to “back into” income. Your Operating Agreement can give you the same right to look under the hood.

Tax Distributions

Oftentimes the business will have income but no cash, since it is reinvesting in the business. However, as a shareholder of an S corporation or a member of a garden variety multi-member LLC, you pay taxes on business profits, not distributions. Theoretically, you could have a big tax bill and never see the cash. How does this work?

The business has net business income after expenses of $100,000, and everyone decides to put the money back into the business, such as inventory purchases. Cool, since everyone agrees, but all the owners have a tax obligation based on the $100,000 (inventory purchases don’t always reduce taxable income right away, but there are rules, so please play along for now). If you are a 25% owner at a 22% marginal tax rate, you have an out-of-pocket tax bill of $25,000 x 22%, or $5,500, before state taxes.

WCG recommends two things when it comes to distributions. First, define and calculate working capital for your business. If the entity needs working capital to operate or for future purchases or initiatives (what we call capital expenditures, or capex for short), how is that calculated? Second, once working capital is defined, what portion is distributed and what is kept in the business?

Let’s run through an example. Your law firm specializes in personal injury, and as such, your revenue is lumpy. To be safe, you and the other partners determine that you need six months’ worth of expenses in working capital. The firm is also moving next year into a new office that needs a build-out. You add that up, and whatever cash is left over is available for distribution.

Sidebar: Your business earns an additional $100,000 and keeps the cash to increase working capital rather than distributing it. Owners of pass-through entities are generally taxed on their share of those profits anyway. At a 22% marginal tax rate, that’s $22,000 in taxes without receiving the cash. The good news is that when the business later releases the retained earnings, distributions are generally tax-free to the extent of the owner’s tax basis. You already paid tax on the profits, and the IRS generally doesn’t get a second bite simply because you finally received the cash.

From there, the Operating Agreement could dictate that a minimum of 40% of profits is distributed to the owners, subject to available cash, the agreed working capital requirements and the distribution limits in state law, unless all owners agree otherwise. Attorneys often call this a tax distribution clause, and it takes the sting out of being taxed on income you never received. One catch for LLCs taxed as S Corps: the Operating Agreement must give each ownership interest identical rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds. A tax distribution clause that favors one owner over another, perhaps because one has a higher personal tax rate, can create a second class of stock and jeopardize the S Corp election.

What WCG recommends is-

  • Determine working capital (time-based operating expenses, plus capex, plus a buffer).
  • Determine a budget.
  • Use math to determine how much you can safely distribute to the owners.
  • True up each quarter or semi-annually to align reality with the budget. If interim profit is higher than budgeted, perhaps another off-cycle distribution can safely occur.

Another common scenario is when you are the minority owner. The majority raises their own wages and stops paying distributions, basically starving you out. My partner would never do that! Really? Ok. For everyone else not living in fantasy land, an Operating Agreement can protect you from this situation.

Capital Calls (Bring Your Wallet)

What happens if a partner won’t contribute capital? When the business needs cash and a member can’t or won’t put in their share, the members who write the check are just being generous to the ones who didn’t, unless there’s a plan. The Operating Agreement can choose among a few common approaches-

  • Dilution. The contributing members’ ownership goes up and the non-contributor’s goes down.
  • Member loan. The contributing members’ money is treated as a loan to the business, repaid with interest before distributions resume.
  • Forced buyout. Repeatedly failing to fund triggers a buyout at a discount.

For an LLC taxed as an S Corp, dilution and member loans need additional care, because ownership changes, shareholder debt and the one class of stock rules have their own consequences. See our Funding Your Own Business section for more information.

Pick one before you need it. It’s a lot harder to agree on the rules after the bank calls.

Deadlock

50-50 ownership with no tie-breaker is a stalemate waiting to happen. Common fixes include naming a neutral third party to break ties, giving one member the deciding vote on narrow issues such as day-to-day operations, or a buy-sell trigger where one owner names a price and the other decides whether to buy or sell at that price. That last one is sometimes called a shotgun clause, and it has a way of encouraging reasonable behavior. Nobody lowballs when they might end up on the other side of the deal.

Transfers, Trusts and Heirs

Everyone seems to have a revocable trust these days, and that’s mostly a good thing. But your Operating Agreement should say whether a member can transfer their interest to a trust, what happens when that member dies, and who gets a vote afterward. A right of first refusal, along with appropriate death and transfer provisions, keeps you from waking up with a new business partner you never picked, such as a member’s heirs or ex-spouse. For an LLC taxed as an S Corp, the trust also has to be an eligible shareholder, which a living trust generally is while the member is alive. After death, it can take a specific election to keep the S Corp election intact.

Tax Provisions Templates Often Miss

Two tax items deserve a look before anyone signs-

  • LLCs taxed as S Corps need S Corp language. Most Operating Agreement templates are written for partnerships, with special allocations, preferred returns and liquidating distributions based on capital accounts. Those provisions are fine in a partnership, but in an LLC taxed as an S Corp they can create a second class of stock and put the S Corp election at risk. See our Ineffective S Corp Elections section for more information.
  • Partnerships need to address the partnership representative. Unless an eligible partnership elects out of the centralized partnership audit regime, it must designate a partnership representative with authority to bind the partnership and its partners in an IRS audit. Who gets that authority, what decisions require consultation, and what must be communicated to the other members belong in the Operating Agreement.

Dispute Resolution

Templated Operating Agreements usually have language about dispute resolution, specifically mediation. Mediation is fine, and some courts require parties to attend mediation before trial. However, mediation is not binding, and the parties don’t necessarily have to show up in good faith. Trials take a long time, anywhere from 12 to 24 months just to get to opening statements.

Arbitration is like mini-court, and the rules of discovery, evidence and procedure are usually more relaxed. It can be expensive, since you are paying for your attorney plus the arbitrator, who is usually a retired judge or attorney. However, it can also be efficient, and it is typically binding.

Regardless of mediation, arbitration or trial, make sure your Operating Agreement has expeditious dispute resolution provisions, and incentives for all parties to be efficient and bargain in good faith.

Business Valuation

If a member wants out, no problem, but what is the business worth? Should you use a formula? Perhaps something based on revenue? A full-blown business valuation (our typical engagement is $5,000 for a conclusion of value)? What if you and your business partners cannot agree on the business valuation expert? Make sure there are provisions in your Operating Agreement.

And once you agree on the price, how is it paid? Agreements often set the value and forget the payment. Lump sum or installments? Over how many years, and at what interest rate? Is the exiting member’s payout secured? What if the business simply can’t afford it? A buyout funded over five years with interest is common, and life or disability insurance can fund a buyout triggered by death or incapacity.

If the value can’t easily be derived from a formula, we often see language where the exiting member and the remaining members each pick a business valuation expert, and those two experts pick a third as a neutral, or some other seemingly detached and disinterested selection mechanism.

Separate Documents Worth Signing

Some protections work better as their own agreements than buried in the Operating Agreement-

  • Non-solicitation and non-disclosure agreements. Non-competes are increasingly hard to enforce, and many states restrict or ban them outright, so don’t count on one. Properly drafted non-solicitation and non-disclosure agreements can still provide important protections, subject to state law.
  • Intellectual property assignment. Copyrightable work created by employees within the scope of employment generally belongs to the employer, but ownership of inventions, pre-existing work and other intellectual property can be more complicated, especially for owners who aren’t on payroll. A written assignment helps put the company’s intellectual property where it belongs.

As we’ve said in the past, just because you are working with an attorney or an accountant doesn’t mean you are working with a smart person. WCG can review your Operating Agreement or consult alongside your attorney when drafting these documents.

Jason Watson, CPA, is a Partner and the CEO of WCG CPAs & Advisors, a boutique yet progressive tax, accounting and business consultation firm headquartered in Colorado Springs, Colorado. With 7 partners and 110 incredible professionals across offices in Colorado, South Dakota, Wyoming and India, WCG serves small business owners, real estate investors and taxpayers worldwide.

Jason Watson CPA LinkedIn     Jason Watson CPA Email

Taxpayer’s Comprehensive Guide to LLCs and S Corps 2025 Edition

Taxpayer’s Comprehensive Guide to LLCs and S Corps 2025 EditionThis KB article is an excerpt from our 420+ page book (some picture pages, but no scatch and sniff) which is available in paperback from Amazon, as an eBook for Kindle and as a PDF from ClickBank. We used to publish with iTunes and Nook, but keeping up with two different formats was brutal. You can cruise through these KB articles online, click on the fancy buttons below or visit our webpage which provides more information.

2027 EDITION IS CURRENTLY BEING WORKED (partial releases throughout November)

LLCs and S Corp Book Amazon LLCs and S Corp Book Kindle LLCs and S Corp Book PDF
$49.95 $39.95 $29.95

Talk to a Small Business CPA About Your Situation

Please use the form below to tell us a little about yourself, and what you have going on with your small business or 1099 contractor gig. WCG CPAs & Advisors are small business CPAs, tax professionals and consultants, and we look forward to talking to you!

The tax advisors, business consultants and rental property experts at WCG CPAs & Advisors are not salespeople; we are not putting lipstick on a pig expecting you to love it. Our job remains being professionally detached, giving you information and letting you decide within our ethical guidelines and your risk profiles.

We see far too many crazy schemes and half-baked ideas from attorneys and wealth managers. In some cases, they are good ideas. In most cases, all the entities, layering and mixed ownership is only the illusion of precision. As Chris Rock says, just because you can drive your car with your feet doesn’t make it a good idea. In other words, let’s not automatically convert “you can” into “you must.”

Let’s chat so you can be smart about it.

We typically schedule a 20-minute complimentary quick chat with one of our Partners or our amazing Senior Tax Professionals to determine if we are a good fit for each other, and how an engagement with our team looks. Tax returns only? Business advisory? Tax strategy and planning? Rental property support?

Text WCG Offices

Text WCG Offices

Need to get in touch through a quick text?  We’ll respond back within a day and get going!

Chat our amazing team

Call Our Amazing Team

If you need to speak to a tax professional now, give us a call and we'll get you connected.

Schedule Discovery Meeting Now

Request a Meeting with WCG Inc

Ready to schedule now and talk about S Corp and reasonable salary and all that gibberish? Let's do it! Here is a link to a Discovery Meeting with one of our Partners or Senior Tax Professionals to understand your tax footprint and objectives, and how WCG CPAs & Advisors might help.

Previous Formation of an LLC or S Corp
Next LLC Liability Protection (Myths, Realities and Charging Orders)
Table of Contents