Why Punish Specified Service Trades or Businesses

Why Punish Specified Service Trades or Businesses

By: Jason Watson / Posted Tuesday, May 28, 2019
Posted By: Jason Watson

Key Takeaways

  • SSTB Overview: Certain professions like accountants, physicians, attorneys, consultants, and financial advisors are classified as Specified Service Trade or Businesses (SSTBs), which limits their Section 199A deduction.
  • Income Thresholds Matter: The SSTB limitation applies only if household taxable income exceeds $157,500 (single) or $315,000 (married, 2018 numbers).
  • Historical Context: Personal Service Corporations (PSCs) were historically taxed at a flat 35% rate, creating a stigma for service-based businesses.
  • Section 199A Deduction: Provides a qualified business income deduction, but penalizes SSTBs potentially to prevent disguised contractor arrangements or encourage economic stimulus through other business types.
  • Theories Behind SSTB Limits:
    • Discouraging disguised W‑2-to-1099 conversions.
    • Favoring non-service businesses that hire employees and stimulate the economy.
  • Critique of SSTB Rules: The economic stimulus argument is inconsistent; some single-person businesses still contribute significantly to the economy.
  • Potential Strategy: If employee salaries exceed shareholder salaries, the business may avoid SSTB classification and qualify for the full Section 199A deduction (suggested approach, not law).
  • Caution: Manipulating salaries on tax returns is illegal; strategies should remain compliant with IRS rules.

Being designated a specified service trade or business, or SSTB for short, for some business owners can appear like punishment. We have this wonderful Section 199A qualified business income deduction but it has rules, and one of the rules is to punish those in the loose category of personal service providers. Specifically SSTBs are accountants, physicians, attorneys, consultants, financial advisors and a few other categories (here is a complete run down of the SSTB list, what we call the dirty baker dozen).

Also, a quick recap- the SSTB designation only affects you if you earn more than $315,000 in taxable income as a household (married filers) or $157,500 (single filers). These are 2018 numbers, and are indexed to not-so-round numbers in future years.

Personal Service Corporations

Prior to the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, personal service corporations (PSCs) were taxed at a flat rate of 35% while garden variety C corporations were taxed at a graduated rate. Why were PSCs disfavored if you will? No one really knows. Online research doesn’t readily show the genesis of this distinct tax schedule; perhaps a look into some Committee notes or the Joint Committee Bluebook would help. Historically it is just one of those things that has been around.

No one seemed to care much about the 35% (pre-TCJA) tax rate since an owner or set of owners could elect to be taxed as an S Corp and pass the tax obligation to each shareholder at his or her individual tax rate. Yes, the highest tax rate prior to TCJA was 39.6% so some thought that the 35% was a deal! However, to pull money out of a corporation (C Corp or PSC) required a dividend and as such that money was taxed at dividend tax rates in addition to the corporate tax rate. For a look at why C corporations are still a bad idea even with a 21% flat tax see our article here.

If for some reason the PSC could not elect S corporation tax status (varying revenue splits, more than 100 shareholders, foreign investors, etc.) the executive team would drive income down with high salaries and / or bonuses which of course are taxed at the individual tax rate. This was undesirable for two reasons; increased payroll taxes and increased IRS scrutiny. IRS scrutiny, huh? In S Corp land your shareholder salary can be deemed unreasonable because it is too low; in C Corp land your shareholder salary can be deemed unreasonable because it is too high. There are a zillion court cases (Law Offices—Richard Ashare, P.C. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1999-282) highlighting this oft-forgotten issue.

So there is a stigma out there that perhaps started with personal service corporations and was reinforced with Domestic Production Activities Tax Deduction (aka QDPA). QDPA came about with Section 199, without the A, and encouraged the manufacturing (stuff), growing (farming) or extraction (oil and gas) of tangible personal property. This is a huge simplification, but as you can see it did not encourage personal services.

Specified Service Trade or Business Penalty

Along comes Section 199A qualified business income deduction which grabs code from PSCs and qualified domestic production activities to provide a deduction for small business owners. Why the heck does Section 199A penalize specified service trades or businesses? Who knows exactly why, but perhaps there is some theory behind it.

Disguised W-2 Compensation
One of the theories is that many attorneys, physicians (especially), accountants, consultants and financial advisors can easily be converted into contractors. Personal service industries can easily follow the rules of contractor status and as such, many might want to convert from a W-2 relationship to a 1099 relationship to grab a Section 199A deduction. Perhaps discouraging a “disguised W-2” business-to-business relationship is one of the theories.

Economic Stimulus
Another theory is that encouraging non-SSTBs such as manufacturing results in a better stimulus to the economy since these businesses usually hire employees and buy buildings or offices. Conversely, the hot-shot surgeon or big-time attorney might be a one-person show. How does this effect things? A one-person show is the limiting factor on revenue and can only work so much. Think of it this way, a hot-shot surgeon doesn’t necessarily hire other surgeons to help out around the office, and as such isn’t stimulating the economy with hiring employees. But you take a manufacturer who is growing and needs employees, perhaps a tax break would help them grow faster and better, and add that much more to the economy.

This is BS

We cry BS on these theories, especially the economic stimulus one. WCG (formerly Watson CPA Group) is an accounting firm and as such is limited on the Section 199A deduction. We’ve grown. We’ve hired. We’ve added to the local economy. If WCG (formerly Watson CPA Group) was rather the Watson FBA Group where we sold stuff on Amazon, we would enjoy the full Section 199A deduction. What makes matters worse, using the Amazon example, is that several online retailers do not hire employees but still get the full qualified business income deduction. There are several examples of one-person shows where the person earns well over $500,000 but only adds to the economy by buying fancy cars and second homes like the hot-shot surgeon or big-time attorney.

Yeah, we are whining over sour grapes. Yes, this is our chosen profession and we could have picked manufacturing or some of other non-SSTB field.

What to Do?

We propose a simple solution to the SSTB problem. If your employee salaries exceed the officer compensation (shareholder salaries), then all bets are off; you are not a specified service trade or business and as such you are entitled to the full Section 199A deduction (again this is our suggestion- it is not law, yet). Specifically Line 8 would be greater than Line 7 on an S Corp tax return. Sure, you could always lie, cheat or steal on the business tax return to embed shareholder salaries into employee salaries… but those taxpayers who are inclined to do something like that are already gaming the system in another way.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an SSTB?

A Specified Service Trade or Business includes professions like attorneys, physicians, accountants, consultants, and financial advisors.

When does SSTB status affect the Section 199A deduction?

Only if household taxable income exceeds the specified thresholds ($157,500 single, $315,000 married, 2018 numbers).

Why are SSTBs limited under Section 199A?

To potentially prevent disguised contractor arrangements and encourage economic growth via hiring businesses.

What is a Personal Service Corporation (PSC)?

Historically, a PSC was taxed at a flat 35% rate and generally included service-based corporations.

Can SSTB limits be avoided legally?

Possibly, if employee salaries exceed shareholder salaries, the business may qualify for the full deduction, though this is not official law.

Does being a one-person business automatically disqualify you from the full deduction?

Not necessarily, but SSTB limitations are more likely to apply.

What happens if my business is a hybrid (service + non-service)?

Only income from SSTB activities may be limited; non-service operations could qualify for the full deduction.

Is it legal to adjust salaries to bypass SSTB limits?

No, manipulating tax returns is illegal and can lead to IRS penalties.

Does Section 199A apply to all businesses?

It applies to many small businesses, but SSTB rules restrict some high-income personal service providers.

Getting Started with WCG

Learn about important tax deadlines, document checklists and due dates, and other essential tax return information.

Getting Started

Jason Watson, CPA is a Partner and the CEO of WCG CPAs & Advisors, a boutique consultation and tax preparation CPA firm located in Colorado, and is the author of Taxpayer’s Comprehensive Guide on LLC’s and S Corps and I Just Got a Rental, What Do I Do? which are available online and from mostly average retailers.

Related Blogs

rental expert pod
October 7, 2025

Rental Expert Pod

Overview of the Rental Expert Pod Specialization matters. WCG’s Pod system lets our CPAs “stay in their lane” — delivering
one big beautiful bill
July 4, 2025

One Big Beautiful Bill (OBBB)

Overview of the One Big Beautiful Bill (OBBB) Before we dive into the nitty gritty of this new bill, here
June 7, 2025

Short-Term Rental Tax Loophole

Key Takeaways The short-term rental (STR) loophole lets losses be treated as non-passive if average stays are 7 days or
March 30, 2025

Jason’s Sabbatical

Is it silly to write in the first-person? Probably. According to a 2022 Harvard Business Review article, a study of
REPSLog
February 26, 2025

Material Participation REPS Log

Key Takeaways Time logs must be kept in real-time to meet IRS “contemporaneous” standards. Record all time spent on rental
February 26, 2025

FinCEN Beneficial Ownership Information

Key Takeaways New federal filing for most small businesses (99% affected) — part of the Corporate Transparency Act starting Jan.
Posted Tuesday, May 28, 2019
Tax Planning Season

Tax planning season is here! Let's schedule a time to review tax reduction strategies and generate a mock tax return.

Tax Planning Services
Bookkeeping Services

Tired of maintaining your own books? Seems like a chore to offload?

Accounting Services

Professional Consultation

Did you want to chat about this? Do you have questions about us? Let’s chat!

The tax advisors, business consultants and rental property experts at WCG CPAs & Advisors are not salespeople; we are not putting lipstick on a pig expecting you to love it. Our job remains being professionally detached, giving you information and letting you decide within our ethical guidelines and your risk profiles.

We see far too many crazy schemes and half-baked ideas from attorneys and wealth managers. In some cases, they are good ideas. In most cases, all the entities, layering and mixed ownership is only the illusion of precision. As Chris Rock says, just because you can drive your car with your feet doesn’t make it a good idea. In other words, let’s not automatically convert “you can” into “you must.”

Let’s chat so you can be smart about it.

We typically schedule a 20-minute complimentary quick chat with one of our Partners or our amazing Senior Tax Professionals to determine if we are a good fit for each other, and how an engagement with our team looks. Tax returns only? Business advisory? Tax strategy and planning? Rental property support?

Text WCG Offices

Text WCG Offices

Need to get in touch through a quick text? We'll respond within a day.

Chat our amazing team

Call Our Team

Need to speak to a tax professional now? Give us a call 719-387-9800 and we'll get you connected.

Chat with a tax pro

Chat With a Tax Pro

Taxes can be tricky. Chat with a WCG human now and get questions answered.

After almost 6 years with this CPA group, there is NO ONE else we would trust to do our taxes.

L. Matisek

See Review

We've worked with multiple bookkeepers and accountants over the years and WCG has completely blown us away.

N. Sellden

See Review

As a novice business entrepreneur they provided me with the tools to both structure and tax my business efficiently

Mayon Hight

See Review

They've made my taxes a breeze and are worth every dime I pay them for the peace of mind their services provide.

Lynn Shannon

See Review

The good folks at WCG have impressed me, as being highly competent, patient & friendly.

Fred LeBlanc

See Review

They've made my complicated business life simple and I'd recommend them to anyone with a slightly complicated-to-overwhelmingly complicated tax strategy!

Nic J

See Review

For nearly nine years, I have had the privilege of working with WCG and their team of exceptionally knowledgeable and experienced CPAs.

Alex Hickman

See Review

Amanda - WCG CPA - You guys have been invaluable in helping us get this business and tax planning setup properly and executed correctly.

Lance Dodd

See Review

WCG is extremely knowledgable, timely and attune to the unique aspects of our businesses.

Carl Protsch

See Review

WCG CPAs are professional and a pleasure to work with.

Nakapan P.

See Review

They go beyond the call of duties to assist me not only with Tax return matters but with any questions on other personal and company tax matters.

Juan Mayorga

See Review

I've always dreaded tax season, but WCG has made things so easy, even as we changed to an S corp. So happy we found them!

Paige de Kock

See Review

It was great to find an accounting firm eager to take on new clients, answer initial questions in depth, and support our “keep it simple” philosophy.

Stuart B.

See Review

Working with WCG was so easy, shout out to Sally Rhoades who handled my complicated tax situation this year wonderfully and was available for all my questions.

Stefani Cinto

See Review

I am so thankful to be a client of WCG CPAs & Advisors.

Carol Kersten

See Review

It's a wonderful and rare treat to find a company like WCG these days with their high level of service, personal approach, and deep knowledge of accounting.

Jeffree Hilton

See Review

Such a great firm. Great communicators, great attention to detail and overall great people.

Jeff Owens

See Review